For this game you will need 5 or 6 baby items and the same number of paper bags.
Place each item in a bag and number the bags. Staple the bags shut. Give each guest an index card and something to write with. Pass the bags around. Each guest should write down what she thinks is in each number bag. Whoever gets the most correct answers wins and receives a prize.
Make sure to pick some harder items, like bow holders for baby shoes or an oddly shaped toy! At the end of the shower, the mom-to-be can keep the baby items.